Minnesota Vikings fans have endured their share of quarterback rollercoasters over the years, but the horizon looks bright as the team gears up for the 2025 season with JJ McCarthy at the helm. In the latest episode of Two Old Bloggers, hosts Darren Campbell and Dave Stefano—veteran voices who’ve been dissecting Vikings football since the late ‘90s—offer an in-depth look at what McCarthy could bring to the table. Aired as part of the Vikings 1st & SKOL production and the Fans First Sports Network, this episode blends optimism, analysis, and a touch of nostalgia to set the stage for what could be an epic year in Vikings land.

The episode is structured around three key themes: McCarthy’s 2025 expectations, the second wave of free agency, and proposed NFL rule changes. With their signature deep-dive style, Darren and Dave weave together historical comparisons, statistical projections, and insider tidbits to paint a vivid picture of the Vikings’ trajectory. Here’s a comprehensive breakdown of their discussion, complete with quotes and subheads to guide you through the purple-and-gold journey.

Theme 1: JJ McCarthy’s 2025 Outlook – From Floor to Epic Potential

A Rookie Year on the Sidelines Sets the Stage

JJ McCarthy, the Vikings’ first-round pick in the 2024 NFL Draft, didn’t see a single regular-season snap last year due to a season-ending meniscus injury. But as Darren and Dave point out, that setback might have been a blessing in disguise. Sitting out gave McCarthy a chance to soak up Kevin O’Connell’s playbook, refine his skills, and prepare for his debut as the presumed starter in 2025.

Darren kicks off the discussion by referencing a segment from Good Morning Football, where analyst Kyle Brandt highlighted a rare historical parallel. “There are 11 quarterbacks since the AFL-NFL merger that sat their first year basically, and then were starters Week 1,” Darren notes. “One of them, a Viking, Dante Culpepper in 2000… Culpepper’s the only one that has led his team to the playoffs in that year as a starter.”

This sets the tone for a broader exploration of quarterbacks who thrived after sitting their rookie seasons—names like Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Michael Vick, Carson Palmer, and Patrick Mahomes. While Darren cautions that context varies for each player, he’s optimistic about McCarthy’s preparation. “JJ McCarthy has been a very, very busy boy,” he says, detailing the quarterback’s offseason work.

Building a Foundation for Success

McCarthy’s development wasn’t idle time. The Vikings and their young QB put in serious effort to ensure he’s ready for 2025. Darren highlights four key areas of focus:

1. Footwork Refinement: “There was a big emphasis on cleaning up his footwork technique… that would also help with his pocket presence movement in the pocket, which is very important for a quarterback’s success,” Darren explains. Improved footwork should boost McCarthy’s accuracy, an area he’s already refining from his Michigan days.
2. Coaching Connection: Weekly meetings with head coach Kevin O’Connell, even while injured, built a strong rapport. “A lot of it was about building relationships with his coach, but they certainly talked about football… the whys, the way that Kevin O’Connell runs the offense,” Darren says. This immersion has McCarthy mastering the playbook—a critical edge for a first-year starter.
3. Virtual Reality Training: Inspired by Jayden Daniels’ standout rookie year, McCarthy used VR to enhance his processing skills. “He’s been doing the same thing… that’s going to help with his processing skills, getting used to the speed of the game,” Darren predicts.
4. Defensive Insight: McCarthy went beyond the offense, joining defensive meetings to understand how opponents attack quarterbacks. “He made a point of reaching out to the defensive players… getting an idea about what are they looking for in their film sessions,” Darren says. This rare initiative underscores McCarthy’s work ethic.

Dave chimes in, emphasizing the team’s role in setting McCarthy up to succeed. “He’s stepping into as good a situation as a young quarterback could be stepping into… a great support system,” Darren adds, pointing to stars like Justin Jefferson, Jordan Addison, TJ Hockenson, and a bolstered offensive line.

Projecting the Numbers: Conservative Floor, Sky-High Ceiling

So, what might McCarthy’s stat line look like in 2025? Darren offers a conservative baseline: “If he’s healthy and he starts all 17 games… 3,700 to 3,800 yards perhaps, 25 touchdowns, a completion percentage of around 65%, low interception rate… maybe around the nine to 10 mark.”

Dave, however, sees that as the floor. “I think they’re the bottom,” he counters, citing comparisons to Trevor Lawrence’s second year (4,000+ yards, 66.3% completion) and even Joe Burrow’s 4,600-yard sophomore campaign. He points to Dante Culpepper’s 2000 season—3,937 yards, 33 touchdowns, 16 interceptions, and a playoff run—as a historical benchmark. “He’s got the supporting weapons… I think it will be better,” Dave predicts, suggesting 35-36 touchdowns could be in reach.

Both hosts agree McCarthy’s mobility adds another dimension. “He does run… he’s got great pocket presence,” Dave says, hinting at a handful of rushing touchdowns to complement his passing stats. With a tough schedule ahead, they project 10-12 wins—enough to win the NFC North and secure a playoff berth.

Theme 2: Second Wave of Free Agency – Bolstering the Roster

Low-Risk, High-Upside Signings

As free agency’s second wave unfolds, the Vikings continue to fine-tune their roster. Darren and Dave break down three notable additions: Tim Jones, Jeff Okudah, and Rondale Moore.

• Tim Jones: A lesser-known wide receiver, Jones is pegged as a special teams replacement for Trent Sherfield. “If he makes the team… he’d be a special teams guy,” Darren says, noting it’s not a game-changer but fills a niche.
• Jeff Okudah: The former No. 3 overall pick in 2020, Okuda’hs career has been marred by injuries and inconsistency. “He struggled when he’s had to play as a pro… but he’s very physical at the point of attack,” Darren observes. Signed to a one-year, low-risk deal, Okudah adds depth to a thin cornerback room. Darren sees it as a trend: “They’ve been taking swings at failed first-round picks… maybe he can find it here in Minnesota.”
• Rondale Moore: At 5’7”, Moore brings a unique skill set post a serious knee injury in 2024. “He’s not gonna be boxing out guys… but he has explosiveness and big playability,” Darren enthuses, envisioning jet sweeps and gadget plays. With Jordan Addison facing a potential three-game suspension, Moore could see early action.

Saying Goodbye to Garrett Bradbury

The Vikings also parted ways with center Garrett Bradbury, a 2019 first-rounder who signed with the Patriots. “It ends a disappointing six-year run,” Darren reflects. Despite mobility in the run game, Bradbury’s PFF grades (peaking at 67.5 in 2022) and struggles against power rushers made him a liability. His release paved the way for Ryan Kelly, a move fans and analysts alike applaud.

Culture as a Free Agency Edge

A standout revelation comes from new signings Jonathan Allen and Javon Hargrave, who cited the Vikings’ top-tier treatment of players and families—backed by the NFLPA’s No. 2 team report card ranking—as a key factor in joining. “That was a significant reason why they signed with the Vikings,” Darren says, quoting Allen’s emphasis on family treatment over money. Dave adds, “The Wilfs are very, very good owners because of it.”

Theme 3: NFL Rule Changes – Shaping the Game’s Future

Packers Push to Ban the Tush Push

At the NFL league meetings (March 30-April 2, 2025, at The Breakers in Palm Beach, Florida), several rule changes are up for debate. The Green Bay Packers propose banning the “tush push,” a play Darren supports eliminating. “It seems to me to be an unfair advantage… it “

“It’s not a football play,” he argues, citing safety and fairness concerns. Dave counters, “It’s an advantage now, but… defenders figured out how to stop the Wildcat,” suggesting it might fade naturally. Fan opinion is split, and with the NFL favoring offense, this rule’s fate is uncertain.

Lions Target Penalty Adjustments

The Detroit Lions propose removing the automatic first down for illegal contact or defensive holding penalties, opting for a five-yard penalty instead. “A lot of these calls seem to be ticky tacky… five yards seems more reasonable,” Darren says, though he acknowledges the Lions’ self-interest after frequent flags in 2024. Dave warns, “The NFL wants to advance the offense… this one’s not gonna pass.”

Playoff Seeding and Overtime Reforms

The Lions also suggest re-seeding playoffs based on regular-season record, not division titles. “It seems like a fair way to do it,” Darren muses, though Dave defends tradition: “I like that if you win your division, you were the best thereof.” Finally, the Eagles push for playoff-style overtime in the regular season—15 minutes, both teams guaranteed possession. “I’d be in favor of this one… it’s fairer,” Darren says, contrasting it with the current coin-flip-driven system.

Listen:

Watch:

Conclusion: A Season of Promise Ahead

Darren and Dave wrap up with palpable excitement for 2025. “I think he will be our longtime franchise quarterback,” Dave declares of McCarthy, envisioning a floor of 3,800 yards and 25 touchdowns that could soar to Mahomes-like heights. The Vikings’ offseason moves and cultural edge bolster this optimism, while rule debates hint at an evolving NFL landscape.

For Vikings fans, this episode is a rallying cry: McCarthy’s debut season could be epic. As Darren puts it, “It’s time to start this thing.” SKOL Vikings!

Fan With Us!
We have your Minnesota Vikings talk amongst the Two Old Bloggers, Darren @KickassblogVike, and Dave @Luft_Krigare. Join the conversation! Fan with us at Vikings 1st & SKOL @Vikings1stSKOL and with our podcast partner Fans First Sports Network @FansFirstSN and Fans First Sports Network’s NFL feed @FFSN_NFL where you get sports takes for the fan, from the fan!